Free · Lessons & patterns of 15 experts · PDF

NEW RESEARCH · OCTOBER 2026

The Experimentation
Puzzle

The Experimentation
Puzzle

Experimentation Maturity isn't linear, and there's no single end state every company should aim for. But most agencies & consultants don't tell that story, they will sell you an easy to understand framework.

How 15 leaders built and scaled their Experimentation Programs, and why no two journeys look the same. Here’s what you can learn from that

✅ The 4 corner pieces of an Initial Experimentation Program
✅ What becomes important when you scale

We'll send you the report with your data. Unsubscribe anytime.

What’s inside

Three pieces from the research.

Three pieces from the research.

Three pieces from the research.

01 · The premise

Why maturity models don’t move you forward

Why maturity models don’t move you forward

Fixed models assume every organization climbs the same staircase. Only 2 of the 15 leaders we surveyed believe in one fixed end state.

The ladder vs. the puzzle

02 · The corners

The four cornerstones every program needs

The four cornerstones every program needs

A clear business reason, leadership support that gives you space, data people trust, and some resources to run with. What each looks like in practice.

Based on a survey of 15 experimentation leaders

03 · Your next piece

Where to start, and what comes next

Where to start, and what comes next

The edge pieces that matter when more teams join, and how to tell which piece your organization should work on next.

Process, capacity, goals, governance & more

Prefer the walkthrough?

Live workshop · Monday 9 & 16 November 2026 · 15:00 CET

Live workshop · Monday 9 & 16 November 2026 · 15:00 CET

Ruben de Boer & Lucia van den Brink walk through the findings live, and take your questions. Sign up and you’ll get the calendar invite and the link to join.

For product, growth & CRO leaders building or scaling an experimentation program

The premise

A maturity model shows where you are. Not how to move forward.

A maturity model shows where you are. Not how to move forward.

A maturity model shows where you are. Not how to move forward.

Fixed models assume every organization climbs the same staircase toward the same end state. Only 2 of the 15 leaders we surveyed believe in one fixed outcome. Politics, industry, size and regulation change the order.

crawlwalkrunfly

The ladder

The ladder

One prescribed sequence. Everyone starts at the bottom and climbs the same way.

The puzzle

The puzzle

Start where you are. With the edges, a corner, or an island in the middle.

01

Organizations don't all follow the same path.

02

Maturity isn't a linear progression through predefined stages.

03

Every organization has its own strengths, gaps and constraints.

04

Each organization and puzzle has a different completed picture.

The research

Built on answers from people who've done the work.

Built on answers from people who've done the work.

Built on answers from people who've done the work.

15

15

15

experimentation leaders surveyed, 13 of them in-house

4

4

4

cornerstones every program needs in place

7

7

7

edge pieces that matter when more teams join

13/15

13/15

13/15

don't believe every company should aim for the same end state

Who we spoke with

André Morys

Erin Weigel

David Swinstead

Stewart Ehoff

Desiree van der Horst

Marta Mijatov

Stuart Clare

Muqtadaa Miandara

+ 7 who answered anonymously

“You can drive a Lambo, but without a driver's licence you're still going nowhere.”

“You can drive a Lambo, but without a driver's licence you're still going nowhere.”

Desiree van der Horst, on whether one sequence of steps works everywhere

Research led by

Together, Ruben & Lucia have helped build 100+ experimentation programs & cultures.

Together, Ruben & Lucia have helped build 100+ experimentation programs & cultures.

Ruben de Boer

Experimentation culture & evidence-based decisions

Lucia van den Brink

Founder, The Initial · in-house experimentation

Your organization has its own experimentation puzzle.

Your organization has its own experimentation puzzle.

Your organization has its own experimentation puzzle.

Get the free report. See which pieces you already have, and where to focus next.

Get the free report. See which pieces you already have, and where to focus next.